April 06, 2009

Discussion of "The Business of Being Born" has begun!


-" 'If I could do that I could do anything.' That's the POWER of birthing, and THAT is what we are taking away from women."

-Giving birth, “This is what it could be if you trusted it. If you believed in this woman. If you believed in her body and her ability.”

-“There really is no informed consent from these women..”

-“People in our culture spend more time and effort researching to buy a car stereo system…than they do checking out what their choices are for birth.”


I am a fifty-one year old woman, am still fertile and have had more than one abortion in my lifetime. I knew from a very young age that I did not want to be a mother, that I had no more interest in having children than I did in being an astronaut or in pole vaulting. I have never felt any maternal yearnings or instincts. Throughout my adulthood when this subject arose and I made my feelings clear the most common reaction was that of surprise and disbelief. “Oh, you’ll change your mind, you’ll see.” people would say. Unbelievably , I had this same experience less than a month ago. I am half a century old and people still think I am going to change my mind!

I am not. However, I have to tell you that watching this film brought up a lot of feelings and thoughts that were very new to me.

Foremost, how could I have grown up as a female in a ‘modern’ society, with a high level of education and access to information and yet have been TOTALLY in the dark regarding the process of birthing. How could I not have questioned the system of mechanized birthing and ‘obstetric intervention’ that exists in our country? How did I, Miss Gotta-know-the-real-deal-behind-every-door, TOTALLY miss the boat on this one? I never questioned the system. Never asked how, what, or why. I can let myself off the hook a little by saying that as I never intended to give birth why should I do the research. But that doesn’t cut it for me. I allowed myself to be duped, hoodwinked, brainwashed. The only picture I had in my head of giving birth was of a woman screaming in agony as a bunch of medically clad humans yelled at her to PUSH, goddamnit, PUSH! Lying on a cold white sheeted table, vulnerable, exposed, and totally dependent on a doctor, usually male, to get this thing out of her once and for all. Followed by "thank god that hellacious experience is over." Never thought about it, never questioned it, never cared.

Man, did this film blast open my world . It was if I was being forced to wake up from a dream, a BAD dream at that, and be dragged into the reality, the beauty, the awe, the truth that I had never seen and it hurt! It hurt like hell to realize that all my views and conceptions about the process of having a baby were wrong. That it could all be very different. It could be private and intimate, loving and warm. It could be sensuous, emancipating. It could be bliss. It could be an experience worth having, worth remembering, worth anticipating. It could be an experience that puts me in touch with the living universe in a way that could change me and enhance my connections to and understanding of nature.

Had I been aware of all this, had I known what I was missing, would my decisions have been any different? Would I have chosen to give birth and have the child be adopted? My mind has reeled with the impact of these questions. I watched the film a second time with my partner David and I cried a lot. Cried for what I missed out on, the experience I will never have.

So I said to David, "You know, I could still probably do it. I could get pregnant, give birth, and give the child to parents who would love it." Together we pondered this, we let our imaginations fly, thought about a couple we know who are looking to adopt, how would it feel to give them a baby. Ultimately I decided, no, I do not wish to do this.

In the past, I chose not to give birth to and or raise a child. And now I choose it again. But this time with full, informed consent.

And THAT is empowering.

14 comments:

karynn71 said...

Lee, I thought I was pretty savvy about all this, especially since I spent a lot of time involved with my sister during her two pregnancies. She had one Caesarean and the other in a 'Birthing Center.' After watching this I realize just how little either of us, or my mother for that matter, really understood about all the facts and choices. I'm so glad that this film was made and that I watched it. I wish it was mandatory for all females to see this as part of their high school education. We are taught more about volcanoes and black holes than about our own bodies.BMM,DNA

oldman said...

Saw this movie some time ago and loved it. Sent a copy late last year to my son and and daughter-in-law in NC who just delivered our first granddaughter last month. Can't say there was much here that was new to me, but with five children I've had more than the usual incentive to study up on the subject. Then too, being a little older than some here, I came of age at a time when natural childbirthing was very much the "in thing." My first was born in '75. It was a natural childbirth at a birthing center in Philadelphia overseen by a doctor known internationally for his work in this area. My wife was attended by midwives, one of whom was actually the mother of a college friend of ours with whom we were then sharing a house. Of course in those days we knew several people who lived on "The Farm," had met Ina May Gaskin, and by the time of delivery had accumulated a virtual library of books on the subject. All of which makes it that much more disappointing to see how the pendulum has swung back in the other direction in the intervening years -- endless drugs, unnecessary caesarians, births scheduled around the convenience of the doctor and even mother and so on. In the medical world today childbirth is clearly viewed more as an illness to be "cured" than a natural process to be aided -- and celebrated. I too wish this film could be made mandatory viewing for every high school student in the country. Appalling that -- as karynn71 put it -- our children are taught more about volcanoes and black holes than their bodies.

jones and jones said...

We enjoyed reading the new post and the 2 comments.
Our 34 year old daughter had a child this year (her second) and they had a wonderful midwife. The process was very similar to what was shown in the film. She became well versed in the subject after her first child birth in the "mechanized" way in a local hospital.She and her husband were unhappy with the use of drugs and induced labor that they felt pressure to have. Of course they were delighted to have a healthy baby but still felt that they wanted complete control over the birth next time around. We were all involved and It was a great experience for all of us. She was thrilled and plans to do it again. The film is an education and it should be shown to all women, and men! so they can make choices. I remember the births of all my children and though it all went well thank goodness I wish I had been aware of my options. Home births simply were not even seen as a possibility back then. Let us hope that things will be changing and the word will spread.

filmluver said...

You picked another winner Lee. I'll be passing the word.
WWW.

Breather said...

I agree with you all, this film ought to be shown to all high school students. It is a fantastic airing of options. We already teach them about their bodies and how they change during adolsence. We teach them how to NOT get pregnant. We should show them the options available when they do get pregnant.

But the AMA will block it. After all, it was the AMA who undermined the practice of midwifery in this country. THEY do not want us to realize that our greatgrandmothers
gave birth at home. They do not want us to remember that when doctors started maternity hospitals the incidents of infections and deaths during delivery went up. ("Oops! We didn't know we should've wash our hands. Sorry about that!")

But that just proves that doctors are like everyone else - they will protect their interests, whether it is in the general public's interest or not. After all, GM bought up and tore down the public transportation systems in several major cities during the 40s and 50s; Phillip-Morris et. al. crushed the "smoking gives you cancer" studies for decades; The Ethyl Group nearly destroyed Claire Patterson because he dared suggest (prove) that leaded gasoline was poisoning us all. Why should we expect the AMA to be above that?

Of course, maybe doctors ARE above that. Maybe they just prefer women to be powerless, to do what they are told, and to not belive in themselves. After all, you can't expect the fashion industry and TV do all the degrading of women, can you?

Though the film got preachy and a few of the women were more annoying than a bad Elvis impersonator, the information presented could improve the lives of more people than any documentary I've ever seen. The quote Lee used rang so true for me: “People in our culture spend more time and effort researching to buy a car stereo system…than they do checking out what their choices are for birth.”

JoAnne 20/20 said...

I saw this movie a few months ago and came across your site today while looking for reviews. I'm impressed with the level of personal expression and sharing in the comments. I'm not sure I could be so honest. I am three months pregnant and planning. The film has been instrumental in helping my husband and I with our choices. Thank you for such a fantastic conversation!

JJperollini said...

I too was not a big fan of the Ricky Lake Show and would never have expected such a great documentary.Thanks for the heads up on this one.

Sammy52 said...

Although I think this was an excellent overview of the topic of child birth, I am surprised that so many women, (as Lee talks about her own lack of knowledge in her posting) are unaware of all this information. Perhaps I and my circle are in the minority of American females but it seems to me that all of us have known pretty much everything shown here for , well, I can't remember not knowing it!I do recall talking with my mother about her experiences at an early age and I guess I just figured that was the normal way. Live and learn!

SILVER said...

WELL, THIS IS A SUBJECT I HAVE NOT THOUGHT ABOUT IN MANY MANY YEARS AND AM NOT QUITE SURE HOW TO ADDRESS
SINCE I AM OBVIOUSLY THE RESIDENT OLDIE HERE AND A WOMAN WHO HAS HAD 5 PREGNENCIES AND 3 CHILDREN, I CAN TELL YOU HOW IT WAS.
NO NATURAL CHILDBIRTH FOR US . JUST HOURS OF LABOR AND THEN BLESSED RELIEF AND THEN A BLESSED CHILD.
NOT SO FOR MY SECOND ,WHO WAS 2 MONTHS PREMATURE. WITH NO IMPUT FROM ME I WAS GIVEN THE DREADED TWILIGHT SLEEP AND LET ME TELL YOU ,IT WAS WORSE THAN YOU CAN IMAGINE. NO CONTROL OVER BODY OR MIND.
SEEING HOW 2 OF MY CHILDREN WERE AT RISK AT BIRTH MY CHOICE WOULD STILL BE TO BE IN A HOSPITAL,BUT IT WOULD HAVE BEEN NICE TO HAVE A MIDWIFE ATTEND.
I AM PLEASED THAT WOMEN HAVE CHOICES TODAY,EVEN THOUGH I DONT AGEE WITH ALL OF THEM (SEE OLDMAN).
BOTTOM LINE TO ME IS THAT THE MIRACLE IS NOT THE BIRTHING BUT THE BIRTH.
SILVER

lee paris said...

Thanks for the great comments everyone.

Welcome to Karynn71, jones and jones, JoAnne20/20, JJperollini and Sammy 52!

And welcome back Breather, we missed you!!!

ptcruiser82 said...

What a great DOC! Who would have believed that Ricky Lake had such a serious and intelligent side. Her show was certainly not indicative of this, Don't forget what came before that, her acting career! Wasn't she the 'fat' girl in a John Water's film? What was the name of that... redone recently with John Travolta?

JackR said...

You are right PTCruiser, Ricki Lake played 'Tracy Turnblad' in John Water's 1988 hit 'Hairspray'. She also did 'Cry-Baby' and a mess of lesser known films over the years before slimming down and getting her own talk show.

CarolynR.T. said...

I knew she looked familiar!

Craft said...

Oh my god, that WAS Ricky Lake. I never would have put that together and I've seen the original movie twice. BMM!!!

Popular Discussions

About Lee Paris